Back to article library

Carlee Russell’s Hoax
The case of Carlee Russell is one of those cases people have a lot of questions about and with the latest admission of a hoax provided by her attorney in the statement he provided below, further raises more questions and only provides one answer; Yes, it was a hoax, but why?

With the latest hoaxed disappearance of a woman named Carlee Russell, in Alabama earlier this month, we have been contacted at the Missing Persons Center with many questions.

Firstly, we must address the fact that there are thousands of people reported missing each year and the reasons why sometimes are simple and other times are very complex, creating mysteries that leave us all asking for answers.

The case of Carlee Russell is one of those cases people have a lot of questions about and with the latest admission of a hoax provided by her attorney in the statement he provided below, further raises more questions and only provides one answer; Yes, it was a hoax, but why?

A statement from Russell’s attorney, Emery Anthony, reads as follows:

“There was no kidnapping on Thursday, July 13, 2023. My client did not see a baby on the side of the road. My client did not leave the Hoover area when she was identified as a missing person. My client did not have any help in this incident — this was a single act done by herself. My client was not with anyone or any hotel with anyone from the time she was missing. My client apologizes for her actions to this community, the volunteers who were searching for her, to the Hoover Police Department and other agencies as well and to her friends and family. We ask for your prayers for Carlee as she addresses her issues and attempts to move forward, understanding that she made a mistake in this matter.”

The above statement is an insult to anyone who has been abducted, trafficked, lost or legitimately reported missing from circumstances out of their control.

Further, it is an insult to the families of missing people who suffer daily not knowing where their missing loved one is, the professionals in law enforcement who do their job to the best of their ability as they did in the Russell hoax.   And let’s not forget about the thousands of volunteers across the globe who tirelessly work to find missing people and keep their stories alive.

And finally, the people who have been hurt the most is the black community who advocate and have been on the frontlines, fighting the fight for equity in resources and media exposure for women of color for years.  Recently, there have been huge gains made in bringing more equity in reporting of women of color and it’s been great to see how many cases we might never have heard about in the past, were coming to the forefront of reporting.

Carlee Russell, Missing Persons Hoax.

Carlee Russell’s hoax encompassed so many areas that were wrong and hopefully the truth will shed light into the motivation people have in faking their disappearance.  The public wants the truth, not a statement from an attorney that clearly confirmed the obvious.

When the truth is revealed, it will bring to light the selfish acts of a person who was on a mission to get attention in any way possible.  Russell didn’t care about anyone but herself and her obsession with a man who scorned her.

Here are the basic reasons why hoaxing your disappearance is not a good idea.

The idea of faking one’s own disappearance might seem intriguing and thrilling, fueling imaginations with thoughts of escape and starting anew. However, the reality of such an act is far from romantic or benign. Faking one’s own disappearance is a serious offense, both morally and legally, and can have severe consequences for individuals involved. In this article, we will explore the reasons why someone shouldn’t fake their own disappearance, shedding light on the ethical, legal, and emotional implications of such a reckless act.

1. Moral Dilemma

The decision to fake one’s own disappearance involves deception and betrayal of trust. By vanishing without a trace, individuals abandon their loved ones, friends, and responsibilities, causing immense emotional distress to those left behind. Families and friends are left bewildered, fearing for the safety of their missing loved one. The emotional toll this takes on them is immense, often leading to feelings of grief, guilt, and helplessness. The act of faking one’s own disappearance can shatter relationships and create long-lasting wounds in the lives of innocent people, making it a morally questionable decision.

2. Legal Consequences

Faking one’s disappearance is not a harmless prank; it is a crime that can lead to serious legal repercussions. Law enforcement agencies dedicate significant resources to locate missing persons, and when a disappearance is found to be a hoax, it diverts precious time and resources away from genuine emergencies. Consequently, individuals caught faking their disappearance may face charges such as filing false police reports, wasting public resources, and obstruction of justice. These charges can result in fines, community service, or even imprisonment, tarnishing the person’s record and future prospects.

3. Emotional Turmoil

The process of faking one’s own disappearance is not as simple as vanishing into thin air. It often involves meticulously planning and executing an elaborate ruse, which can cause intense stress and anxiety for the person involved. Maintaining the deception over time can be emotionally draining, leading to feelings of isolation, paranoia, and constant fear of being caught. The person may find themselves living a life of perpetual lies, cutting ties with loved ones and living in a state of perpetual insecurity. The emotional burden of such an existence can be overwhelming, leading to serious mental health issues.

4. Lost Opportunities and Second Chances

Faking a disappearance might be an attempt to escape from life’s challenges and start over. However, this act denies individuals the opportunity to face their problems head-on and find healthier solutions. Facing adversity and learning from mistakes are crucial parts of personal growth. By evading these challenges, one misses the chance to grow as a person and build resilience. Moreover, opportunities for reconciliation, forgiveness, and personal transformation are lost when relationships are shattered through deception.

5. Damage to Trust

Trust is the foundation of any relationship, whether it be with family, friends, or colleagues. Faking one’s own disappearance irreparably damages the trust others have placed in the individual. Even if the person decides to return eventually, rebuilding trust will be an uphill battle. The betrayal and deception will always linger in the minds of those affected, making it difficult for them to fully trust the individual again.


Faking one’s own disappearance might seem like a tempting escape, but the consequences far outweigh any temporary relief it might offer. The moral implications of deceiving loved ones, the legal ramifications, emotional turmoil, and damage to trust make it an ill-advised and irresponsible course of action. Instead of resorting to such extreme measures, seeking support from friends, family, or professional counseling can provide a healthier way to address the challenges and struggles of life. Remember, embracing challenges and taking responsibility for one’s actions is the path to personal growth and true liberation.

The Carlee Russell hoax has reopened wounds of many families of missing people.  Most of those missing people will never be able to change their mind and come back to a safe place, a home with parents that care about them.  There are many people, especially children missing who no one ever cared about and even in their missing person profiles, there is no recent photos, no good explanation of what could have happened to the child and they never had a minute of media exposure, articles or even a public alert of any type.

Instead, grown adults who are lacking something from within and need to see how the world would be without them are hoaxing their disappearance and it always ends up the same way, they get revealed.

There are many people who want to know the truth because there are so many lines of trust that were broken and so many people who genuinely cared about the outcome of the Russell case. Most people seemed relieved she ended up being safe and uninjured, but she did a lot of damage to not only her family, the local community in Hoover, AL., but also to the public trust all over the world with those who advocate for missing people and their rights every day.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Get the latest on Everything Missing Persons